Alarm Notification Profile Missing From Notification Block

I created a secure smtp email profile (gmail). Successfully sent a test email. Created Notification Profile with this email profile. The problem is the notification profile doesn't show up in the notification block within the alarm notification pipeline. I see my existing Twilio profile but cannot see or select the new email one. The only other option I see is "None". I closed designer and reopened with no success. I also tried creating a new pipeline with the same results.